Menu
Review Highlights
“Me neither, but they're these delicious homemade fried balls of rice and cheese.” in 2 reviews
“The other week I got their chicken marsala.” in 2 reviews
People also searched for
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Italian
in Seafood, Mediterranean, Greek
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Our Original Pizzeria.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
30 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Terry H.Hudson, NY02Apr 25, 2024
A great local old school pizza joint!
Specialty slices always ready to go at a great price ($7 for 2 slices and a soda!)
Definitely not fancy, but I always look for awesome hole-in-the-wall places.
And yes, mind your P's and Q's, as a joke I said "Gimme 2 slices" all gruff and thought a rolling pin was going to head my way :-)Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jessica B.Burlington Flats, NY151Jul 29, 2023
Tomato pie was delicious. Worth the drive . Staff was very sweet . The place smelled of fresher baked pizza and had many options to choose from . Perfect little corner pizza place .
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - James D.Hudson, NY14452Jul 5, 2023
Some of these reviews are complete bullshit. I've been coming here for overhalf my life...theres a reason for that. Hell I even worked there before. I'm here to tell you, this place is one of a kind. The people who run that place are basically family to Me. I order there all the time because the food homemade from scratch. I looooove pizza and if there's one place I recommend....it's this place right here.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jan 14, 2022
Ordered 2 subs and fries with a 2 liter.
Cheeseburger sub was trash. It said Angus beef and I'm sure that's what it says on the Frozen meat patty box of caiman but it was not that good. It was also cold and the delivery guy used one of those hot bags but it didn't really help.
Chicken Parm sub was greasy and turned my buddy's stomach. He also said it wasn't that good like the sauce had really no flavor.
We both ordered like OK a full-size sub is probably too much but I'm eating it, but we both pretty much stopped at half because neither sub was very good.
Fries were pretty good. They were also cold when they got to us. Add to that I ordered a 2 L and they sent one of those little 1 L bottles. If you were out of 2 L fine but send me 2 1 liter bottles (to be fair it was the 1.25L but still, 4$ for 2L you're not losing money giving me 2 1.25L or at least adjusting the price).
Won't be ordering here again. I wanted to go 3 stars or but the food wasn't great besides the fries.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Todd Y.Sharon, CT0161Apr 4, 2023Updated review
This place is an absolute hole in the wall type of place that's been there forever and you gotta know it's there. The dinners are outstanding. Chicken Marsala, to die for. This is dinner with attitude. Remember your pleases and thank you's or they will remind you. Lol.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Dec 16, 2022Previous reviewI'm new to Original Pizzeria, all I can say is the food is very well done. The specials are worth looking into.
- Anthony A.Delmar, NY518141Mar 18, 2017
Fancy it is not.
Stopped in with kids, each with a friend, large pepperoni pie, 12 cut, 4 sodas $21. All agreed they loved it. I use to visit 10 years ago when I worked in the area, since then been back only once (brought coworker whose whole family swears by this place). Wish it was closer.
Lively banter with the lady who may be the owner, nice selection of individual slices also.
Not the upscale cookie cutter place if that's your thing. If it's not then please try this place!Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Mathew G.Ballston Spa, NY03Apr 30, 2021
This place is a joke. We ordered 2 pizzas , mozzarella sticks and aroncini. They were out of aroncini. They called and let us know. Great. The food was a half hour late soaked in grease burned in some places raw in others. So we called asking for a refund. After stating the company line of "every order is handmade" to explain why our food took 2 hours to arrive. They were rude and told us to call grubhub. We did. After 80 dollars worth of greasy inedible pizza was refunded through grubhub plus the place calls me back and tells me their driver is coming to pick up the food the owner wants to see why we got a refund. NOPE. You must be crazy. Never again.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Regan H.Nantucket, MA32139Jun 7, 2020
Got pickup on a sunday night at 6 pm. All I ordered were meatballs and the pasta carbonara which comes with a side of bread and side salad. First off, my salad was missing the dressing I ordered. Secondly, my "bread" side was a cold, hard, and dry garlic knot that tasted like it had been sitting out for a day. Then I get to my pasta which had undercooked pancetta and the saltiest carbonara sauce I've ever tasted. Perhaps the only saving grace were the meatballs, which were small in size but came with a decent portion and were pretty good. Really disappointed in the pasta, can still taste the salt from the couple bites that I could eat.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Anna K.Waterford, NY9811Apr 25, 2019
One of my most favorite pizzerias ever! Everything from the dough to the sauce is freshly made, the dinners, subs, calzones are delicious. Check Facebook for their daily specials. The value you get for the money is unbelievable! This was my delicious homemade lunch today....
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Italian
in Pizza, Italian