New Haven Pizza

I was out late night and decided to stop by and get a pizza before I came home. I ordered a small Bacon and Cheese Pizza with wings. The pizza was not great and when I arrived home to open the wings, the wings looked liked they have been out all day and just heated up. The pizza tasted like the pizza you would get from Chuck E. Cheese but there pizza is actually better. The bacon looked a little funny and actually didn't look like bacon at all. I ate two slices and one chicken wing and threw it out. I would have given them a 1 star but the girl behind the counter was very nice. She came out to my car and told me my order was ready.

Don't bother! I ordered a delivery of ziti with meatballs and there were no meatballs. I called to complain and was told they broke up the meatballs but I could find no sign of meat anywhere.

I ordered a medium pizza with peppers sausage and pepperoni and onion rings my first time trying this pizza place it was so good perfectly cooked, so my experience with this pizza place,l give you 5* thank you l will order again

I ordered a a Chicken Broccoli Ziti dinner with chicken tenders. The food took an hour to get there and it was ordered at about 3 am. I got food poisoning, threw up the next day all day was told I could get 40 dollars in credit because of this. When I called to get the food I was laughed at by the worker and told I should've went to the hospital. Horrible customer service and a shame that I was being laughed at for getting sick from food that I was sold. Don't go here.

I was a bit surprised by this one I'm not going to lie. We were supposed to go somewhere else that day but plans changed and we ended up in New Haven on a whim. The place didn't look like much and I didn't check the reviews before going there. I honestly don't agree with all the low reviews at all. We got a large party pizza, some mozzarella stick and some potato skins. They were quick with it too. My boyfriend went in there to place to order it and talked to the staff. He says they were very nice and pleasant unlike past reviews said. Staffing has definitely changed a lot recently so I would give these new people a chance. The pizza we got was good. I don't know if it was the best New Haven style pizza out there but it was good. Where we are from in Connecticut has a lot of pizza places so we do have a bit to compare to. But this place was actually really good. The mozzarella sticks had a good cheese pull which I always look for when it comes to those. Their potato skins were VERY greasy though. If you're not a fan of a lot of grease maybe pass on those. My friends and I like that kind of stuff so we didn't mind at all. Their margarita pizza I have to recommend though. It was absolutely fantastic. Four of us demolished a whole party pizza in about a half hour.
It may not look like much from the outside but it has definitely changed from their older reviews. I would hands down give them a chance if you've been disappointed in the past. I had a great dinner which is a bit hard to come by lately with all the supply chain issues now.

I'm not a New Haven native but visit often to see my in-laws. I'm very aware of the New Haven pizza rave and in fact, have tried some of the best pizza here myself. However, I'm not sure how long that reputation will last with this namesake restaurant. I believe the city of New Haven should get an injunction to stop this restaurant from using its name because they are ruining it!

The pizza was the worst I have ever had in a very long time. Not only were the ingredients stale and dried out the tomato sauce tasted cheap and likely store bought. I also ordered chili cheese fries and believe it or not, it was basically fries with a can of black beans dumped over it. To make things worse, a little after eating I started suffering from a painful stomachache and I suspect the food here has something to do with it.

I am very curious how these people are staying in pizza business, especially in New Haven. I have a feeling the misleading name must have something to do with it -- probably by luring unsuspecting out of towners. This place MUST go away.

Trash. Pizza is eh and wasn't cut. They gave Uber Eats half of the wrong order. Chicken sandwich was sloppy and better off in the trash. Should of checked Yelp reviews prior to ordering on Uber Eats.

I placed a late night order from New Haven Pizza online and it was delivered within a half hour. We ordered the 24" Party pizza-I couldn't even walk through the door with the box!

It came pre cut into smaller square slices so it was easy to share with the group. Very good and quick food post-bar on a Saturday night!

I ordered for the first time through grubhub and it took 2 hours for the pizza to arrive. When it arrived it was like warm and the calzone was hard. The driver was extremely rude and never got out of his car and just beeped the horn. When i called new haven pizza back the owner gets on the phone and immediately stars yelling at me the the driver is there. After trying to explain to him the entire issue all he continued to do is raise his voice and yell. SOME CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!! I will NEVER prefer or recommend this place!!!!!

Got an email from the owner on regards to my complaint , really bad attitude towards the customers , a take it or leave it attitude , bad customer service , won't recommend this place to my worst enemy .