Formaggio's Pizzeria

Formaggio's is serving up some seriously delicious Pizza ova'here and they're making their slices so freakin BIG that it doesn't even fit on a plate. Now THIS is what I'm talkin bout people!!
Whoever said there's no such thing as "too much of a good thing" never had a slice of Pizza from Formaggio's.
Plus Counter Service is friendly and you'll also find plenty of indoor seating options available.

Come And Get Your MUNCH On!!

3.4 on yelp and 4.8 on Google? Y'all are hating. Came here 30 mins before closing and the staff was kind enough to let me eat in. Ordered a chicken Murphy and it was baller. Very tender chicken, potatoes cooked well, rigatoni pasta had a nice bite to it dish had a bit of spice kick and the sauce was really tasty. Salad was fine and bread was soft. Huge portion for a $17 entree. Excellent value, accommodating staff, highly recommended

I've come here on my lunch a few times. I haven't had anything to complain about. The pizza is good and nice and crunchy crust with every bite. The brushetta was delicious, i think they toasted the bread then and so that tasted fresh. One day, i decided to get the bellly buster. It wasn't as overwhelming as i thought it might be, which is good for me because i don't like oversized portions. I actually ate and fully enjoyed the whole thing. Will be going again for sure.

They are now on DoorDash! Ordered delivery from here - chopped greek salad which was good and eggplant parmigiana which was very good! The sauce and cheese are delicious and there is a decent amount of eggplant. It's Huge portions and excellent pricing. Large enough for 3 people to share.

We ordered a family special for pickup a few weeks ago. This is the restaurant that replaced Rocco's pizza. This place is mediocre at best. Pizza was bland. Caesar salad was nothing but lettuce and bottled dressing. Garlic bread was about as good as packaged frozen. Mozzarella sticks were decent. The price charged was higher than their actual price listed on their menu. There is so much other mediocre pizza around, no need to come back.

Recently ordered from here for the first time. Got the chicken parm & eggplant parm dinners. Both were ready on time and were very good. Portions were quite generous. So glad to finally find a local place that makes eggplant parm that I like. I'll be ordering from here again.

Really should be 3.5 stars but didn't have that option.

Absolutely tragic. Hands down the worst pizza in NJ. Stunningly bad.

The pie was soggy, thin and had almost no toppings. Disappointed in every way possible. Will never go back.

Dominos just down the road is better.

The food and the service were great, the atmosphere is perfect for an easy night out for some great Italian cooking. Sauce was on point.

Love the lasagna, chicken parm sub, and eggplant parm here. Portion sizes are good too!

Formaggio's denies paying customers from using the bathroom. Employee told our son to "use the Purell." Better pizza elsewhere (and you can use their restroom).