Brothers Pizza

Got the Stuffed meat pie and the Margherita Pie. both were good, but I prefer the Stuffed meat pie . It was loaded with toppings and tasted amazing. Delivery on the other hand took forever. The food did come hot.

Possibly the worst pizza I've ever ordered on delivery. The mushrooms were from a can and the peppers were slimy. Mozzarella sticks and chicken fingers are also defrosted frozen food. So gross.

Couldn't believe this , all I wanted was a nice philly cheese for lunch and I get this. I call back and ask the guy why the bread is burnt and he tells me I toast the bread. I'm like really you call this toast. Alright my man it's toasted alright. I never again

I love their pizza here. Came here because I was in the area and in need of pizza ! Of all the pizza places nearby, Brothers seemed to have the most promising reviews. I came by at noon, so the place was pretty crowded, but I was able to place my order almost immediately once I decided what I wanted .

They have a selection of about 8-10 pies on display, many of which have meat toppings. I opted for a plain slice and a vodka slice. I also asked the employee to not heat it up too much and he was very accommodating.

The pizza itself was delicious and filling. My only tiny critique would be that the plain sauce had more sauce than cheese on it, but other than that both slices are delicious. The vodka sauce was delicious, creamy, just the right amount of tomato-y. The slices are perfectly thin, still foldable, and just the right amount of doughy. I don't typically like a charred and crunchy crust/bottom, so this pizza was very much to my liking.

Overall, staff is very pleasant and prices are moderate. I think I paid close to 6$ for the two slices. Seating might be difficult to find during the lunch rush but otherwise would highly recommend :)

Never have I ever tasted a plain cheese pizza this bad. The pizza was thin and to my surprise the dough was still undercooked.

I rarely do this kind of reviews but I just couldn't help it. It was that bad.

I'm going to have to try their pizza next time, but this visit I wanted a cheesesteak. The bread was good and the meat was tasty. Just wish there was more meat on the sandwich.

Ordered from delivery.com and was pleasantly surprised how good it was! Ordered a white pie (delicious!) and chicken fingers (a little too oily for me). I will order again from them.

Alright so I'll keep it straight forward. Pizza here is not bad but the dough is not as good as some of the other pizza places (other top 2) in Bayonne. We bought a buffalo chicken pie yesterday and it tasted more like a Domino's Pizza or something similar ... Not the usual pizzeria style that I've gotten in Bayonne.

Pizza felt a little dry.

Buffalo Wings on the other hand was actually good.

Wings were soggy, garlic knots were dry and no flavor, Marinara sauce was watery, pizza was somewhat ok. Would never order again

Just moved here from
Brooklyn , I heard Bayonne had some great pizza but brothers isn't one. Pizza looked old and taste even worse. Wasn't even hot when it arrived, thanks but no thank you to Brothers Puzza