Menu
What's the vibe?
See all 30
Inside
30 photos
See all 13
Outside
13 photos
See all 109
All photos
109 photos
Review Highlights
“Well made third wave drinks like flat whites and cortados, as well as flavored drinks for those with a coffee sweet tooth.” in 3 reviews
“So when in Sag Harbor, sit and smell the roses or in this case the coffee or better yet taste it at Sag Town.” in 10 reviews
“My husband and I both enjoyed the quality of matcha with almond milk.” in 3 reviews
Location & Hours
Other Coffee & Tea Nearby
in Breakfast & Brunch, Coffee & Tea
Amenities and More
About the Business
Business owner information
Shane D.
Sag Harbor's favorite coffee joint. Exclusively serving La Colombe coffee along with specialty beverages, fresh pastries, and light fare, we offer something for everyone.
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Sagtown Coffee.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
97 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Jul 8, 2023
This place makes really good smoothies and the staff is friendly.
This place has something for everyone (coffee, smoothies, vegan friendly options, ice cream...)
I didn't get the coffee but the freshly ground beans smell amazing.
The ambiance is very chill.
I would recommend this place to everyone.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 1491498Aug 14, 2023
What a zoo. Still once you get past the cramped and crowded entrance and place your order you are the subject to screaming staff yelling out " number 15 ! "as if officiating a football game.
That said, if you can handle all the overly loud poor choice of hip hop music while joining ten other " detainees " desperately waiting until your number is screamed out!!
You take your bag... still warm from being toasted , unwrap your long awaited lunch and there lies the most beautiful Turkey club I ever laid eyes on.
Better yet it was just perfect in every way
It's now my go to for Sandwiches etc. I'll just bring my earplugs next timeHelpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jul 16, 2023
Cute coffee shop and lots of yummy treats. I got an iced cold brew with the monkey smoothie. The smoothie was delicious if you're a peanut butter fan!! We also got the vegan carrot cake muffin, blueberry muffin, chocolate croissant and regular croissant. All were really good and I liked that they had vegan and gluten free options. The cafe isn't too small and has seating both inside and outside. My order came out pretty quick despite it being quite busy. It's right in town and you can walk to a bunch of different shops and restaurants. Def check out this spot if you're in the area!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 800155800Sep 17, 2022
Very chic, local coffee spot right on Main St. in Sag Harbor. Very clean with a large selection of coffee, lattes, tea, and other morning drinks. They also have a very elevated morning food selection like avocado toasts, omlettes, etc.
You can get takeaway or stay and eat as there are a few tables with umbrellas outside. Very cute and will definitely be back when I return to Sag!Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Aug 15, 2022
I have always enjoyed going to Sagtown. Whether it is 6:30am before going to work or lunch time, there is always something to eat here. Earlier this spring on a cold day, I tried the chia seed pudding. I haven't specifically heard of or tried a chia seed pudding other places, so I have no point of comparison. The chia seed pudding itself was good and berries on top tasted fresh. There did seem to be a lot more of the pudding than the berries. On a more recent trip, I went into the store around lunchtime and ordered an iced chai and açaí bowl. The iced chai was good and had a good ratio that wasn't too sweet or too heavy on the milk. The way that the açaí bowls work, all of them have the same açaí base and then you add toppings from a list. Each topping is $1 (none of the toppings are included in the buying of the bowl). I added 4 toppings and enjoyed the bowl.
While I enjoyed each of my meals at this place, I would say that it is important to note that there is always a line, a good amount of people either waiting or eating, and that the priced are slightly inflated for location. I think that for simple things like toppings on the açaí bowl, it would make more sense for some toppings to be less than others. For example, the smattering of chia seeds don't need to be the same price as a good serving of mangos. In all, I look forward to going back here for a quick lunch or a breakfast.Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0 - 11348713076Jun 6, 2023
Love that they serve La Colombe oat milk latte on draft. Lines were fairly long early afternoon.
Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 4Oh no 0 - 15044661679Oct 27, 2022
I had a hot cuppa Chino to go it was both the flavoring and Delish. This is very cute Establishment
Helpful 11Thanks 0Love this 13Oh no 0 - Jul 6, 2023
Very loud. The service people were yelling over the smoothie blenders in Spanish to each other. Barely could hear the music. An hour until closing, they start shutting everything down, so don't expect any hot food if you go in later in the day. The cashier was nice. She was trying her best. I can tell she was kinda embarrassed about the loud yelling. Didn't see a pour over coffee station, so don't expect that if you are a real coffee person. They have LA Colombe coffee, which is good. Wide range of only their coffees. So don't expect different roasters to display their coffees. If there was single origin or better than good to great coffee, I didn't see it. The barista pulling shots made me a very fine doppio. They do have ice cream/ gelato and smoothies, which my daughter loved. It's located in the back of another clothing retail shop, which is fine. Has an alleyway with tables to sit at. Pets are welcomes in the alleyway tables, not inside (which I completely understand). The store is actually nice. Good for a quick fix, but I'm not adding it to my go-to places to have coffee or to lounge around at.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 342371252Jun 19, 2022
Came here a couple of times for the matcha latte. Ordered pickup and it was ready quickly. My husband and I both enjoyed the quality of matcha with almond milk. Everything was consistently correct and staff was friendly. Would definitely recommend the matcha latte!
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0